Skip navigation

One Nation’s Poor Behaviour Disguised as Political Disagreement

Post the highly successful Queensland Driving Law Rally, the President and Treasurer of the Legalise Cannabis Queensland (LCQ) Party, Jacki Verne, had cause to write to Senator Malcolm Roberts regarding the conduct she personally experienced and conduct witnessed and reported by LCQ’s Party Secretary, volunteers and attendees, of (in particular) a One Nation (ON) speaker.

She wanted to distinguish political disagreement from poor behaviour, noting that ON is entitled to disagree with LCQ. But democracy requires respect. Disagreement does not give anyone licence to demean, intimidate or deliberately provoke people whose views differ from their own. LCQ demonstrated that respect on the day.

Although the LCQ rally was booked for 12:00 pm, ON did not finish speaking and begin leaving the stage until approximately 12:10 pm, when ON Speaker Scott Challen questioned whether LCQ had a permit. Mr Challen repeated himself several times and Jacki had responded, but finally went to retrieve LCQ’s permit to show Mr Challen in an effort to resolve the situation. She later spoke with a police officer who informed her that she was under no obligation to show Mr Challen, or anyone else associated with the ON rally, LCQ’s permit. 

After subsequently locating Mr Challen and showing him the permit, he then accused LCQ of trying to take “their” stage. Jacki explained that LCQ had paid for the stage from 12:00 pm through the same supplier. He eventually grudgingly acknowledged the situation but then told Jacki that she “stunk”! Such a personal remark had absolutely nothing to do with permits, stage bookings, political policy or resolving any dispute. It was simply a demeaning and belitting behaviour.

LCQ’s Party Secretary also provided an account of what occurred while attempting to access the stage. She and another volunteer Committee Member began moving LCQ’s rally speakers towards the stage. LCQ’s Party Secretary recalled that the female MC for ON became increasingly aggressive, yelling at LCQ’s people and encouraging other ON supporters to become involved. LCQ Party volunteers stood back and waited for ON to move away before attempting to set up LCQ’s signs.

LCQ’s Party Secretary further reports witnessing Mr Challen push one of LCQ’s female volunteers, throw LCQ’s signs away and tear a sign from a volunteer’s hands and run off with it. LCQ’s Party Secretary also observed abusive and aggressive behaviour from at least four people associated with the ON gathering. The people controlling the music then began blasting it out and making derogatory comments about LCQ’s rally attendees over the microphone, including comments that they “stunk”.

This is particularly concerning given that those being subjected to these comments were a mix of medicinal cannabis patients, health and legal professionals, veterans and other invited speakers. The situation deteriorated to the point that police had to be called back (they had been in attendance for the ON rally) because LCQ volunteers and attendees were being intimidated and threatened. Despite having paid to use the stage, LCQ ultimately did not use it. Given the aggression that had already occurred and the fact that the confrontation had put LCQ’s rally behind schedule, the decision was made not to attempt to use it and risk further escalation.

Brisbane_RDT_Rally_(7).png

There is another aspect of this incident that ON’s leadership should take particularly seriously. There were medicinal cannabis patients present who support both ON and Legalise Cannabis. They did not come looking for a confrontation between political parties. They came because the issue of medicinal cannabis and Queensland’s drug driving laws directly affects them. Many of those people left disgusted by what they had witnessed and told LCQ members they were reconsidering their support for ON as a result.

Of particular concern to those watching was that much of the intimidating and aggressive behaviour they witnessed was directed towards women, an observable pattern with a direct impact on the people who witnessed it. Political disagreement did not drive those people away. The behaviour they witnessed did. Mr Challen’s subsequent social media posts made it clear that he did not understand what LCQ’s rally was about or the position being advocated. 

Jacki approached Senator Roberts personally and raised what was occurring with him, he responded in words to the effect of: “It’s a democracy. He doesn’t agree with you”. As a human resources professional, Jacki found that response deeply disappointing from someone in a leadership position. Political disagreement was never the complaint. The complaint was about behaviour. In a professional environment, a leader responding to a report of intimidating or aggressive conduct by characterising it merely as a difference of opinion would raise serious concerns about leadership judgement and conflict management.

Senator Hanson has previously expressed support for medicinal cannabis, and medicinal cannabis patients exist across the political spectrum. They are ON voters, Legalise Cannabis voters, Labor voters, Liberal National voters, Greens voters and people who have no political affiliation whatsoever. They are patients, workers, business owners, professionals, parents, veterans and members of regional communities.

The issue LCQ was rallying about was whether a patient who lawfully uses prescribed medicinal cannabis should lose their licence because THC is detected when they are no longer impaired, while patients taking other prescribed medications are generally dealt with according to impairment and their capacity to drive safely. People are entitled to disagree with LCQ’s proposed solution. They are also entitled to challenge the evidence. That is democracy.

Intimidating volunteers, interfering with another group's event, removing their signs, making personally degrading comments and ridiculing attendees is not meaningful political debate. It is bullying behaviour. The conduct people witness from those participating in political events shapes their judgement of the parties those people appear alongside. On this occasion, medicinal cannabis patients who support One Nation witnessed behaviour they regarded as intimidating, aggressive and demeaning, particularly towards women, and some left questioning whether they could continue supporting ON. LCQ Party would hope that is not the standard ON wishes to represent.

LCQ respected ON’s right to assemble, speak and complete its rally. When their scheduled finish time of 12:00 pm arrived, which was also the commencement time of LCQ’s rally, LCQ did not interrupt or attempt to take over the stage, allowing ON additional time to finish and expected the same respect when it was LCQ’s turn. Jacki does not expect ON, Mr Challen or Senator Roberts to agree with Legalise Cannabis Queensland, but expects people participating in Australian democracy to be able to disagree without intimidation, degradation or aggression and expects political leaders, irrespective of party, to recognise the difference.

Brisbane_RDT_Rally_(12).png

At time of publication, Jacki had not yet received a reply from Senator Roberts (the rally was held 25 August) and the Party wonders if she ever will.